易野者,無禮文也。
孔子見子桑伯子,子桑伯子不衣冠而處。
To be rustic and unrefined is to be wanting in ritual and elegant adornment.
弟子曰:「夫子何為見此人乎?
」曰:「其質美而無文,吾欲說而文之。
Once, when Kongzi met Zisang Bozi, the latter was going about without a proper cap and gown. A disciple asked, “What is your opinion of this man, master?” “His essential character is good,” said Kongzi, “but he is devoid of refinement—I would like to give him advice so that he could become refined.” When Kongzi left, one of Zisang Bozi’s retainers was displeased and asked, “What is your opinion of Kongzi?” “His essential character is good,” Zisang Bozi replied, “but he has too much external refinement—I would like to give him advice so that he could rid himself of this.” Thus, it is said that one who cultivates both his essential nature and his external refinement is a man of quality.
」孔子去。
子桑伯子門人不說,曰:「何為見孔子乎!
To be sound in one’s essential nature but deficient in external cultivation is to be rustic and unrefined.
」曰:「其質美而文繁,吾欲說而去其文。
」故曰文質脩者謂之君子;有質而無文謂之易野。
Zisang Bozi was rustic and unrefined—he wanted to make the way of men the same as that of horses and oxen, so Zhong Gong85 thought his simplicity of manner excessive.
子桑伯子易野,欲同人道於牛馬。
故仲弓曰太簡。
When, above, there is no enlightened Son of Heaven and, below, no worthy regional lords, then the realm will be devoid of the Way.
上無明天子,下無賢方伯。
天下為無道,臣弒其君,子弒其父,力能討之,討之可也。
When an officer assassinates his ruler and a son, his father, then it is permissible to use force to punish the perpetrator as long as this can be effected.
當孔子之時,上無明天子也。
故言「雍也可使南面」,南面者,天子也。
In Kongzi’s time, no enlightened Son of Heaven reigned above, so he said, “Even Yong [Zhong Gong] could be made to face south.” The one who faces south is the Son of Heaven. The reason he said Yong could be made to face south is as follows: when Yong asked Kongzi for his opinion of Zisang Bozi, Kongzi said, “Simplicity—it too will do.” Zhong Gong said, “To be habitually respectful but act simply in leading the people—will not this do as well?” “What Yong says is right,” said Kongzi.
雍之所以得稱南面者,問子桑伯於孔子,孔子曰:「可也,簡。
」仲弓曰:「居敬而行簡,以道民,不亦可乎?
Zhong Gong understood well how to deal with evolving circumstances.
居簡而行簡,無乃太簡乎?
」子曰:「雍之言然。
」仲弓通於化術,孔子明於王道,而無以加仲弓之言。
Kongzi understood the kingly way, but he was unable to add to what Zhong Gong said.